Stop Regurgitating & Start Creating: Pivoting Your SEO Strategy to Outsmart AI Overviews (AIOs)

Mid-2025, many brands are starting to experience big drops in organic traffic and clicks due to their answers being served at the top of the search engine results pages (SERPs) in AI-generated Google responses. Since searchers are getting their answers neatly summarized right in SERP, they simply don’t always need to click through to those blue links.

But to me, it’s about more than just traffic drops due to AI summaries… That’s just one of the current problems for SEO professionals when battling for rankings in the era of artificial intelligence. 

Now, more than ever, if your content strategy is built on summarizing what already exists online, you’re not just behind — you’re actively contributing to a growing problem.  To describe it, I’m coining the term primary content degradation, AKA, a huge lack of truly original content online.

In an age of AI-generated responses (like Google’s AI Overviews (AIO)) and other algorithmic shifts, recycling ideas isn’t just lazy — it’s dangerous to your brand’s authority, visibility, and differentiation.

It’s time to stop spinning old narratives and start creating something new. That means generating primary content: fresh data, unique insights, and original perspectives that only you can provide, and that searchers need to click on your full website to obtain.

What Is Primary Content?

Primary content refers to original material that offers new insights, data, or perspectives. Unlike secondary content, which compiles or summarizes existing sources (literally, what AIO and tools like ChatGPT are doing), primary content is built from your brand’s own research, experiences, and audience interactions.

Think of it like the difference between a journalist reporting from the field versus someone writing a recap of that article. Primary content brings something new to the conversation — something search engines and real people are hungry for.

Examples of Primary Content:

• First-party survey data
  
• Customer interviews or testimonials
  
• Proprietary research reports
  
• Behind-the-scenes processes
  
• Unique case studies
  
• Internal performance data
  
• UGC (user-generated content) with narrative framing
  
• Experiments or tests within your industry

Why Primary Content Matters Now More Than Ever

The release of Google’s AI Overviews marks a turning point. With generative summaries increasingly satisfying basic search intent, brands that only paraphrase what’s already out there risk becoming obsolete.

Here’s what’s happening:

• AI Overviews surface the same aggregated knowledge faster than any brand could hope to achieve with robust topic clusters to support their funnels.
  
• Google’s Helpful Content updates reward originality, first-hand experience, and depth, not caring for regurgitated, thin, or templated work.
  
• Trust signals are more critical than ever, and unique data builds trust. When you contribute something new, you become a source, not just a repeater.

When we offer truly unique, complex content that can’t be distilled down to a two-sentence AIO summary — and we’re the only source of that information — searchers have to click on our site to learn more and obtain their answers.

How to Generate Your Own Unique Data & Insights

You don’t need a research team or a six-figure budget to create primary content. You just need curiosity, consistency, and a few creative tactics. 

Here’s how to get started:

1. Leverage UGC (User-Generated Content)

Your audience is already creating content — reviews, photos, questions, comments. Rather than treating UGC as throwaway social fodder, repurpose it into content that tells a story.

Example:
A hiking gear brand collects Instagram photos from real customers using its products on trails. Instead of just reposting them, the brand creates a visual guide: “What Real Hikers Are Wearing on the Appalachian Trail.” Each image is accompanied by quotes, terrain conditions & gear lists sourced from real users.

2. Tap into Testimonials & Support Conversations

Mining your sales or support interactions for trends can spark unexpected content ideas grounded in real user needs.

Example:
A software company notices several customers asking about automating monthly reporting. They turn that into an in-depth blog series: “How 62% of Our Customers Automated This Annoying Task — and How You Can Too.”

3. Run Quick Surveys or Polls

Use tools like Typeform, Google Forms, or even Instagram Stories polls to collect data on your audience’s opinions, behaviors, or preferences. Then analyze and share the results in context.

Example:
A skincare brand runs a poll: “What’s your biggest frustration with SPF?” After collecting responses, they build a content series around the top five concerns — using real quotes and numbers to anchor their POV.

4. Develop Case Studies With Real Metrics

Whether you’re a service provider, sell products, or a SaaS platform, don’t just say your product works — show it with real numbers and client outcomes.

Example:
An SEO agency publishes a case study on a client who grew their organic traffic 150% after a site migration. It includes the strategy, screenshots, challenges, and measurable results. This kind of transparency builds credibility and ranks well.

5. Share Internal Experiments & Behind-the-Scenes Insights

Even if it’s not perfect or finished, sharing the process of something you’re building or testing can be valuable.

Example:
A startup shares a blog post titled “We Rewrote 300 Meta Descriptions — Here’s What Happened.” It walks through what worked, what didn’t, and what they learned. It’s part experiment, part tutorial — and totally original.

Break Out of the Blog: Go Beyond Text to Be Less Replicable

Many brands are still stuck in a “write the article, publish the webpage” mindset. While written content will always have its place (trust me, as a Content Strategist for over a decade, I get it), AI can now replicate — or even summarize — those formats with alarming ease. 

What’s harder for it to mimic? Human nuance. Emotion. Personality. Format diversity.

To stay ahead, we need to branch out from just text-based pages to different content forms and lean into mediums that aren’t as easily scraped, spun, or summarized.

Why Non-Text Formats Stand Out:

• Video shows body language, tone, and real-time reactions — things that are hard for AI to reproduce or for users to fake.
  
• Social content reflects immediacy, context & cultural relevance.
  
• Graphics like charts, graphs, infographics, etc. can be generated easily with a lot of free modern tools.
  
• Podcasts and audio convey trust and intimacy in a way written content often doesn’t.
  
• Webinars, events & community discussions offer real-time interaction, which is inherently unique and hard to replicate.

These mediums aren’t just harder for AI to summarize and regurgitate — they also build a deeper human connection. All that to say, they get their moment to rank on the SERPs on their own outside of short snippet summaries.

How to Use These Formats to Your Advantage:

• Turn a blog post into a short-form video or story-driven Instagram Reel where a team member explains the takeaway in plain language.
  
• Record customer interviews on Zoom and cut them into short testimonial clips with captions.
  
• Host a live Q&A or “Ask Me Anything” on LinkedIn or Instagram to collect real-time content and insights you can repurpose into evergreen assets.
  
• Create behind-the-scenes footage of your product or process. Authenticity wins over polished, perfect cinematic products here.
  
• Launch a podcast mini-series around a trend you’ve spotted in your industry — bonus points if you bring on your own customers or team members as guests.

The goal is not to abandon written content, but to layer it with richer, more dimensional formats that are harder to clone and more rewarding to engage with.

So, How Do You Ensure This Content Still Ranks?

Originality is critical — but it’s not enough on its own. Publishing unique insights or fresh data won’t automatically land you on page one unless it’s supported by a smart, SEO-driven strategy. Here’s how to ensure your primary content is also findable:

• Validate Topic Demand: Use tools like Google Search Console, Ahrefs, or AlsoAsked to identify topics your audience is already searching for. Look for gaps where primary content would stand out — e.g., common questions with weak or repetitive results.
  
• Pair Content with Clear Search Intent: Structure your unique insight in a way that aligns with what searchers are really trying to find. Answer key questions, build around related terms, and optimize for skim-readers and search engines alike.
  
• Optimize Supporting Assets: Even with formats like video or audio, pair them with SEO-friendly transcripts, summaries, and schema markup. It helps Google understand and rank your non-text assets — and it boosts discoverability.
  
• Use Internal Linking & Hub Structures: Integrate your primary content into broader topic clusters to support visibility. A unique case study performs better when it’s linked from an evergreen pillar post, FAQ hub, or category page.

Pairing originality with optimization is how you ensure your content both adds value and drives traffic.

Be the Source, Not the Echo

In a crowded digital landscape, regurgitating what already exists is the fastest way to become invisible in the robotic eyes of Google.

Instead, own your perspective. Build from your experience. Create from your data. 

Whether it’s a customer quote or a trend spotted in your inbox, your next best piece of content might already be within reach — it just needs a frame.

Primary content isn’t about being louder. It’s about being useful, real, and undeniably you. It will also help you recover some of those lost organic clicks from AIOs. So really, why not?

Ready to Rebuild Your Organic Strategy for the AIO Era?

At Greenlane, we help brands develop SEO strategies that go beyond best practices — strategies grounded in originality, intent-matching, and performance. Whether you’re looking to produce content no one else can replicate or make sure that content ranks, we can help.

Let’s make your site the original source. Explore our SEO Services today.